In today’s church, the question Jesus once asked His disciples—“Who do you say I am?”—is just as critical as it was in the first century. A recent Ligonier Ministries / Lifeway Research survey of self-identified evangelicals revealed alarming statistics:
- 73% believe “Jesus is the first and greatest being created by God.”
- 43% say “Jesus was a good teacher, but was not God.”
If these numbers are accurate, large segments of our churches are embracing a view of Christ that mirrors the ancient heresy of Arianism. This isn’t merely a theological debate—it’s a gospel issue. If we get Jesus wrong, we get the gospel wrong.
First-Century Bridges and Ditches
The gospel was no easier to accept in the first century than it is today. Paul wrote:
“Since God in His wisdom saw to it that the world would never know Him through human wisdom, He has used our foolish preaching to save those who believe. It is foolish to the Jews, who ask for signs from heaven, and it is foolish to the Greeks, who seek human wisdom.”
(1 Corinthians 1:21-22)
As Michael Green observes in 30 Years That Changed the World, Jewish and Greek cultures provided both bridges and ditches to the gospel. The Roman road system, Jewish monotheism, and the Greek translation of the Old Testament opened doors for the message of Christ. Yet there were also deep “ditches”—obstacles that made acceptance difficult.
For Jews, the stumbling block was a Messiah who claimed equality with God rather than political deliverance. For Gentiles, it was the claim that there is one God who is also three persons—a concept foreign to both Jewish and Greco-Roman thought.
The Challenge of the Trinity
The idea that God is “one in essence and three in person” has no perfect earthly parallel. Common illustrations—like water as liquid, solid, and vapor—fall short and can even mislead.
The hardest step for both Jew and Gentile was accepting the incarnation: Jesus Christ as fully God and fully man. This truth has been denied, doubted, and debated from the first century onward. And it remains one of two essential doctrines that separate authentic Christianity from counterfeits (the other being salvation by grace through Christ’s finished work, not by human merit).
The Arian Crisis and the Nicene Creed
In the fourth century, a priest named Arius taught that Jesus was created by God the Father, and thus was neither coeternal with Him nor of the same substance. This heresy caused widespread confusion.
In 325 AD, Emperor Constantine convened the Council of Nicaea to bring unity and clarity. The resulting Nicene Creed affirmed that Jesus is:
- “God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made, consubstantial with the Father.”
The creed also declared the full personhood and deity of the Holy Spirit. Later councils, and the Athanasian Creed in the 6th century, further safeguarded the doctrine of the Trinity. Historically, baptism required affirmation of these truths.
Why This Still Matters
For nearly 1,800 years, mainstream Catholicism and Protestantism have stood united on the Trinity and Christ’s divinity. While we expect groups like Islam, Jehovah’s Witnesses, and Mormonism to reject these truths, the growing denial within evangelical circles is deeply troubling.
If today’s church allows confusion about Jesus’ identity to spread unchecked, we risk repeating history—not in defending the truth, but in tolerating heresy. The pressing question for every generation remains:
“Who do you say I am?”
Get this wrong, and you lose the gospel.
If Jesus is not fully God and fully man, then the gospel collapses. The church of every age must contend for this truth—not just in creeds and history books, but in the hearts and minds of its people today.
Looking Ahead
To guard the gospel, we must clarify what Scripture means by “Son of God” and “begotten.” These terms are key to understanding Jesus’ unique relationship to the Father and His eternal nature. We will explore these in the next article.
For Discussion
- Why do you think so many self-identified evangelicals today misunderstand or deny the full divinity of Jesus?
- What are the dangers of seeing Jesus as only a created being or just a moral teacher?
- Why is the doctrine of the Trinity essential to the gospel and not just a secondary issue?
- How would you personally answer Jesus’ question: “Who do you say I am?”—and why is that answer central to your faith?
- How can we explain the Trinity and the incarnation to others in ways that are faithful yet understandable?